Overcoming Baby Duck Syndrome: How Repeated Use Improves Acceptance of Interface Updates
Users often prefer older versions of interfaces due to a cognitive bias known as the baby duck syndrome, where their first experience with an interface becomes the benchmark against which all future updates are judged. However, an experiment conducted by researchers from HSE University produced an encouraging result: simply re-exposing users to the updated interface reduced the bias and improved their overall perception of the new version. The study has been published in Cognitive Processing.
Mobile and computer interfaces have become an integral part of daily life: in 2024, Russians spent an average of eight hours online each day—nearly half of their waking time. During these hours, we rely on programs, applications, and websites to support our communication, work, and entertainment. However, many people resist interface updates, even when they significantly improve usability. Researchers attribute this to the baby duck syndrome—a cognitive bias in which a user's first experience with an interface becomes imprinted as the standard against which all future versions are judged.
Until recently, the baby duck syndrome has primarily been explored in the context of user experience (UX) and interface design. Most insights have come from UX designers and usability experts who shared their observations through blogs and articles. However, there is still limited scientific evidence on the psychological mechanisms underlying this phenomenon. Researchers at the HSE Laboratory for Cognitive Psychology of Digital Interface Users conducted two experiments to better understand why users are often reluctant to accept changes to interface design.
In the first experiment, researchers compared users’ perceptions of the old and new versions of the Airbnb app. Participants were asked to complete a series of common tasks: find accommodation using filters, save its details, and set up an account. The second experiment was carried out using a custom-built student portal that featured two versions differing in colour scheme and menu item placement. In both experiments, participants were divided into experimental and control groups: the experimental group interacted with two different versions of the interface, while the control group used the same version twice.
After completing the tasks, participants evaluated the interfaces’ convenience and overall impression using standard scales: the System Usability Scale (SUS)—recently adapted for Russian-speaking users by the laboratory’s researchers—the SUPR-Q, and the semantic differential scale.
Both studies revealed a clear trend: users tend to rate the interface they first interact with more favourably, regardless of its actual features. For example, in the Airbnb experiment, the older version received higher ratings despite improvements in the new version’s functionality. Similarly, with the student portal, users gave more positive feedback about the first version they saw, even though the design differences were minimal.
Ekaterina Kosova
'It is important to note that the baby duck syndrome is driven not only by familiarity from regular use but also by deeper psychological mechanisms: the first interaction with a system creates an emotional anchor that is hard to overcome,' explains Ekaterina Kosova, Junior Research Fellow at the Laboratory for Cognitive Psychology of Digital Interface Users and co-author of the study.
Interestingly, differences in how users perceived the new and old interface versions appeared not only in their conscious evaluations but also in objective measures such as task completion speed and participants’ emotional engagement.
However, the scientists observed that simply increasing the time spent with the new interface led to more positive evaluations. In the control groups, where participants used the same version of the website twice, a slight increase in ratings was observed with repeated use. This suggests that a positive attitude toward an interface can develop even after multiple interactions. Therefore, increasing the frequency and duration of interface use can help mitigate negative impressions caused by updates.
According to the researchers, companies developing digital products can leverage this insight to lessen users’ negative perceptions of new interface versions.
Nadezhda Glebko
'This evidence is important for interface designers and developers, as it sheds light on why users may react negatively to updates. By understanding the baby duck syndrome, companies can create strategies for smoother update rollouts and communicate new features more effectively to help users adapt,' sums up Nadezhda Glebko, Junior Research Fellow at the Laboratory for Cognitive Psychology of Digital Interface Users and co-author of the study.
See also:
HSE Researchers Teach Neural Network to Distinguish Origins from Genetically Similar Populations
Researchers from the AI and Digital Science Institute, HSE Faculty of Computer Science, have proposed a new approach based on advanced machine learning techniques to determine a person’s genetic origin with high accuracy. This method uses graph neural networks, which make it possible to distinguish even very closely related populations.
HSE Economists Reveal the Secret to Strong Families
Researchers from the HSE Faculty of Economic Sciences have examined the key factors behind lasting marriages. The findings show that having children is the primary factor contributing to marital stability, while for couples without children, a greater income gap between spouses is associated with a stronger union. This is the conclusion reported in Applied Econometrics.
Fifteen Minutes on Foot: How Post-Soviet Cities Manage Access to Essential Services
Researchers from HSE University and the Institute of Geography of the Russian Academy of Sciences analysed three major Russian cities to assess their alignment with the '15-minute city' concept—an urban design that ensures residents can easily access essential services and facilities within walking distance. Naberezhnye Chelny, where most residents live in Soviet-era microdistricts, demonstrated the highest levels of accessibility. In Krasnodar, fewer than half of residents can easily reach essential facilities on foot, and in Saratov, just over a third can. The article has been published in Regional Research of Russia.
HSE Researchers Find Counter-Strike Skins Outperform Bitcoin and Gold as Alternative Investments
Virtual knives, custom-painted machine guns, and gloves are common collectible items in videogames. A new study by scientists from HSE University suggests that digital skins from the popular video game Counter-Strike: Global Offensive (CS:GO) rank among the most profitable types of alternative investments, with average annual returns exceeding 40%. The study has been published in the Social Science Research Network (SSRN), a free-access online repository.
HSE Neurolinguists Reveal What Makes Apps Effective for Aphasia Rehabilitation
Scientists at the HSE Centre for Language and Brain have identified key factors that increase the effectiveness of mobile and computer-based applications for aphasia rehabilitation. These key factors include automated feedback, a variety of tasks within the application, extended treatment duration, and ongoing interaction between the user and the clinician. The article has been published in NeuroRehabilitation.
'Our Goal Is Not to Determine Which Version Is Correct but to Explore the Variability'
The International Linguistic Convergence Laboratory at the HSE Faculty of Humanities studies the processes of convergence among languages spoken in regions with mixed, multiethnic populations. Research conducted by linguists at HSE University contributes to understanding the history of language development and explores how languages are perceived and used in multilingual environments. George Moroz, head of the laboratory, shares more details in an interview with the HSE News Service.
Slim vs Fat: Overweight Russians Earn Less
Overweight Russians tend to earn significantly less than their slimmer counterparts, with a 10% increase in body mass index (BMI) associated with a 9% decrease in wages. These are the findings made by Anastasiia Deeva, lecturer at the HSE Faculty of Economic Sciences and intern researcher in Laboratory of Economic Research in Public Sector. The article has been published in Voprosy Statistiki.
Scientists Reveal Cognitive Mechanisms Involved in Bipolar Disorder
An international team of researchers including scientists from HSE University has experimentally demonstrated that individuals with bipolar disorder tend to perceive the world as more volatile than it actually is, which often leads them to make irrational decisions. The scientists suggest that their findings could lead to the development of more accurate methods for diagnosing and treating bipolar disorder in the future. The article has been published in Translational Psychiatry.
Scientists Develop AI Tool for Designing Novel Materials
An international team of scientists, including researchers from HSE University, has developed a new generative model called the Wyckoff Transformer (WyFormer) for creating symmetrical crystal structures. The neural network will make it possible to design materials with specified properties for use in semiconductors, solar panels, medical devices, and other high-tech applications. The scientists will present their work at ICML, a leading international conference on machine learning, on July 15 in Vancouver. A preprint of the paper is available on arxiv.org, with the code and data released under an open-source license.
HSE Linguists Study How Bilinguals Use Phrases with Numerals in Russian
Researchers at HSE University analysed over 4,000 examples of Russian spoken by bilinguals for whom Russian is a second language, collected from seven regions of Russia. They found that most non-standard numeral constructions are influenced not only by the speakers’ native languages but also by how frequently these expressions occur in everyday speech. For example, common phrases like 'two hours' or 'five kilometres’ almost always match the standard literary form, while less familiar expressions—especially those involving the numerals two to four or collective forms like dvoe and troe (used for referring to people)—often differ from the norm. The study has been published in Journal of Bilingualism.